ASVMEB September 17, 2014 Minutes

VICTORIA WHITMORE
- EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR -

JANICE K. BREWER
- GOVERNOR -

ARIZONA STATE VETERINARY MEDICAL EXAMINING BOARD
9535 E. DOUBLETREE RANCH RD., STE. 100 « SCOTTSDALE, ARIZONA 85258
PHONE: (602) 364-1-PET #@ FAX: (602) 364-1039

WWW.VETBOARD.AZ.GOV

MINUTES
September 17, 2014
Board Room, at 8:30 a.m.
9535 E, Doubletree Ranch Rd.
Scottsdale, Arizona 85258

Members Present: Dr. Brian Serbin, Mr. James Loughead, Dr. Darren Wright, Ms. Julie Young (left
at 2:50p.m.}, Dr. Les Hatfield, Dr. James Christensen, Ms. Deb Gullett (left at 4:00p.m.), Dr:
Christina Bertch-Mumaw, and Ms, Julie Mumford, C.V.T.

Staff and Legal Counsel Present: Ms. Victoria Whifmore, Executive Director (E.D.); Ms. Mary
Williams, Assistant Attorney General (A.A.G}; Ms. Gina Pickering, Compliance Specialist and Ms.
Tracy Riendeau, C.V.1., Investigations.

1. CALL TO ORDER
Dr. Brian Serbin, Chair at 8:30 a.m.

Roll call: Ms. Julie Mumford, C.V.T.

I. INITIAL INVESTIGATIVE REVIEW

1. 14-78, In Re: Eric Sapan, D.V.M.

After discussion and consideration, a motion was made by Dr. Bertch-Mumaw and
seconded by Dr. Wright, fo accept the Investigative Committee’s recommendation
and dismiss this issue with no violation. Motion passed unanimously.

2. 14-79, In Re: Gurushabd Khalsa, D.V.M.

Dr. Khalsa was present with attorney, David Stoll, and made statements. After
discussion and consideration, a motion was made by Dr. Bertch-Mumaw and
seconded by Ms. Mumford, to disagree with the Investigative Committee's
recommendation and dismiss this issue with no violation. Motion passed unanimously.

3. 14-81, In Re: Otto Stanisiaw Jr., D.V.M.

Attorney, David Stoll, was present to monitor. After discussion and consideration, a
motion was made by Dr. Christensen and seconded by Dr. Berich-Mumaw, to accept
the Investigative Committee’s recommendation and dismiss this issue with no
violation. Motion passed unanimously.

eamexrersromee

Arizona State Veterinary Medical Examining Board — September 17, 2014- Final

4, 14-82, In Re: Erica Jenkins, D.V.M.

Attorney, David Stoll, was present to monitor. Ms. Donna Ferrante made a statement
on behalf of Ms. Cynthia Ferrante. After discussion and consideration, a motion was
made by Dr. Christensen and seconded by Dr. Bertch-Mumaw, to accept the
investigative Committee's recommendation and dismiss this issue with no violation.
Motion passed unanimously.

5. 14-83, In Re: Elena Beis, D.V.M.

Attorney, David Stoll, was present to monitor. Ms. Donna Ferrante made a statement
on behalf of Ms. Cynthia Ferrante. After discussion and consideration, a motion was
made by Dr. Wright and seconded by Dr. Bertch-Mumaw, to accept the Investigative
Committee's recommendation and dismiss this issue with no violation. Motion passed
unanimously.

6. 14-84, In Re: Lisa Schnier, D.V.M.
Dr. Schnier was present and made statements. Ms. Carrie Smith was present and
made statements. After discussion and consideration, a motion was made by Dr.
Serbin and seconded by Mr. Loughead, to accept the Investigative Committee’s
recommendation and dismiss this issue with no violation. Motion passed, 7 ayes, 2
nays (Ms. Young and Dr. Hatfield).

7. 14-87, In Re: William Dean, D.V.M.

After discussion and consideration, a motion was made by Ms. Gullett and seconded
by Dr. Hatfield, to accept the Investigative Committee's recommendation and dismiss
this issue with no violation. Motion passed unanimously.

8. 14-88, In Re: Maggie Weston, D.V.M.
Attorney, David Stoll, was present to monitor. After discussion and consideration, a
motion was made by Ms. Mumford and seconded by Dr. Berfch-Mumaw, to accept
the Investigative Committee's recommendation and dismiss this issue with no
violation. Motion passed unanimously.

9. 14-89, In Re: Deborah Chapman, D.V.M.

After discussion and consideration, a motion was made by Dr. Hatfield and seconded
by Dr. Bertch-Mumaw, to accept the Investigative Committee's recommendation and
dismiss this issue with no violation. Motion passed unanimously.

Further discussion took place and the Board directed staff to contact, consulting
veterinarian, Dr. Petcu, to discuss his submission fo the Board in response to the case.

lll. INFORMAL INTERVIEWS AND BOARD DELIBERATION

1. 14-93: In Re: Kelly Anderson, D.V.M

Dr. Anderson was present with attorney, David Stoll, and made statements and answered
questions. Ms. Sharon Canady and Ms. Mandi Larca were present, made sfatements and
answered questions. Mr. and Mrs. Bob Maskell were present telephonically, made
statements and answered questions. Ms. Grace Reed was present telephonically, made
statements and answered questions.

‘Atizona State Veterinary Medical Examining Board — September 17, 2014- Final

ema:

After discussion and consideration, a motion was made by Dr. Serbin and seconded by Ms.
Gullett to find Dr. Anderson in violation of A.R.S. § 32-2232 (21) as it relates to A.A.C. R3-11-
502 (L) (3), (4), (5), (6), (7), (8), (9), (10), and (11) as indicated in the premise inspection
report. Roll call: Dr. Serbin, aye; Mr. Loughead, aye; Dr. Wright, aye; Ms. Young, aye; Dr.
Hatfield, aye; Ms. Mumford, aye; Ms. Gullett, aye; Dr. Bertch-Mumaw, aye and Dr.
Christensen, aye. Motion passed unanimously.

After further discussion and consideration, a motion was made by Dr. Hatfield and
seconded by Dr. Serbin to find Dr. Anderson in violation of A.R.S. § 32-2232 (21) as it relates
to A.A.C. R3-11-502 (K) (2) and (3) as indicated in the premise inspection. Roll call: Dr.
Serbin, aye; Mr. Loughead, aye; Dr. Wright, aye; Ms. Young, aye; Dr. Hatfield, aye; Ms.
Mumford, aye; Ms. Gullett, aye; Dr. Bertch-Mumaw, aye and Dr. Christensen, aye. Motion
passed unanimously.

After further discussion and consideration, a motion was made by Dr. Serbin and seconded
by Dr. Wright to find Dr. Anderson in violation of A.R.S. § 32-2232 (18) for allowing premise
staff to extract teeth and vaccinate animal's without supervision. Roll call: Dr. Serbin, aye;
Mr. Loughead, aye; Dr. Wright, aye; Ms. Young, aye; Dr. Hatfield, aye; Ms. Mumford, aye;
Ms. Gullett, aye; Dr. Bertch-Mumaw, aye and Dr. Christensen, aye. Motion passed
unanimously.

After further discussion and discussion, a motion was made by Dr. Serbin and seconded by
Dr. Hatfield to find Dr. Anderson in violation of A.R.S. § 32-2232 (12) as it relates to R3-11-501
(1) failure to provide professionally acceptable procedures for not maintaining a premise in
compliance with the Arizona Revised Statutes and Administrative Rules and allowing staff fo
practice veterinary medicine. Roll call: Dr. Serbin, aye; Mr. Loughead, aye; Dr. Wright, aye;
Ms. Young, aye; Dr. Hatfield, aye: Ms. Mumford, aye; Ms. Gullett, aye; Dr. Berfch-Mumaw,
aye and Dr. Christensen, aye. Motion passed unanimously.

2. 14-71; In Re: Priscilla Muhoho, D.V.M.
Dr. Muhoho was present with attorney, David Stoll, and made statements and answered
questions. Mr. and Mrs. Goetsh were present, made statements and answered questions.
After discussion and consideration, a motion was made by Dr. Berich-Mumaw and
seconded by Dr. Serbin to find Dr. Muhoho in violation of:
ARS. § 32-2232 (21) as it relates to R3-11-502:
¢ (H) (3) for failure to record the animal's heart rate and respiration rate in the medical
record at a minimum of every 15 minutes while anesthesia is being administered; and
¢ (1) (7) (b) for failure to record in the medical record the amount of fluids that was
administered to the dog on March 13, 2014.
Roll call: Dr. Serbin, aye; Mr. Loughead, aye; Dr. Wright, aye; Ms. Young, aye; Dr. Hatfield,
aye; Ms. Mumford, aye; Ms. Gullett, aye; Dr. Bertch-Mumaw, aye and Dr. Christensen, aye.
Motion passed unanimously.

A.R.S. § 32-2232 (12) as it relates to A.A.C. R3-11-501 (1) failure to provide professionally

acceptable procedures for:
¢ Inappropriate amount of fluid administration to a dog while under anesthesia with
expressed concerns of kidney dysfunction; and

Arizona State

Veterinary Medical Examining Board —- September 17, 2014 - Final

¢ Dispensing an NSAID to a dog with expressed concerns of kidney dysfunction and
not notifying the pet owner of the potential side effects.
Roll call: Dr. Serbin, aye: Mr. Loughead, aye; Dr. Wright, aye; Ms. Young, aye; Dr. Hatfield,
aye; Ms. Mumford, aye; Ms. Gullett, aye; Dr. Bertch-Mumaw, aye and Dr. Christensen, aye.
Motion passed unanimously.

3. 14-72: In Re: John McGee, D.V.M.
Dr. McGee was present with attorney, David Stoll, and made statements and answered
questions. Mr. and Mrs. Goetsh were present, made statements and answered questions.
After discussion and consideration, a motion was made by Dr. Berfch-Mumaw and
seconded by Ms. Gullett fo find Dr. McGee in violation of:
ARS. § 32-2232 (21) as it relates to R3-11-502:

¢ (L) (7) (b) for failure to record in the medical record the amount of fluids that was

administered to the dog on March 17, 2014.

Roll call: Dr. Serbin, aye; Mr. Loughead, aye; Dr. Wright, aye; Ms. Young, aye; Dr. Hatfield,
aye; Ms. Mumford, aye; Ms. Gullett, aye; Dr. Berftch-Mumaw, aye and Dr. Christensen, aye.
Motion passed unanimously.

After further discussion and consideration, a motion was made by Dr. Bertch-Mumaw and
seconded Dr. Hattield to find Dr. McGee in violation of:
A.R.S. § 32-2232 (22) Medical incompetence in the practice of veterinary medicine:
e For failure to perform an initial urinalysis on the dog on admission on March 17, 2014;
¢ For failure to monitor the dog's urine function and production throughout the day on
March 17, 2014;
e For failure to monitor the dog's urine specific gravity throughout the day on March
17, 2014; and
e For failure to document the dog's condition throughout the day on March 17, 2014.
Roll call: Dr. Serbin, aye; Mr. Loughead, aye; Dr. Wright, aye: Ms. Young, aye; Dr. Hatfield,
aye; Ms. Mumford, aye; Ms. Gullett, aye; Dr. Bertch-Mumaw, aye and Dr, Christensen, aye.
Motion passed unanimously.

After further discussion and consideration, a motion was made by Dr. Serbin and seconded
by Dr. Bertch-Mumaw to find Dr. McGee in violation of A.R.S. § 32-2232 (12) as it relates to
R3-11-501 (1) for failure to communicate the potential seriousness of the dog’s kidney
condition with the pet owner. Roll call: Dr. Serbin, aye; Mr. Loughead, aye; Dr. Wright, aye;
Ms. Young, aye; Dr. Hatfield, aye; Ms. Mumford, aye; Ms. Gullett, aye; Dr. Bertch-Mumaw,
aye and Dr. Christensen, aye. Motion passed unanimously.

4, 14-73: In Re: Stephen Wanick, D.V.M.
Dr. Wanick was present with attorney, David Stoll, and made statements and answered
questions. Ms. Sandra Lawes was present, made statements and answered questions. After
discussion and consideration, a motion was made by Ms. Mumford and seconded by Dr.
Bertch-Mumaw to find Dr. Wanick in violation of:
ARS. § 32-2232 (21) as it relates to R3-11-502:

¢ (H) (2) for failure to document in the medical record an examination of the animal

within six hours before anesthesia is administered or surgery is performed, including

Arizona State Veterinary Medical Examining Board - September 17, 2014 - Final

the animal's temperature, heart rate, respiration rate, diagnosis and general
condition; and
e (H) (3) for failure to document in the medical record the animal's heart rate and
respiration rate immediately after giving the animal a general anesthetic and
monitored and recorded a minimum every 15 minutes while anesthesia is being
administered.
Roll call: Dr. Serbin, aye; Mr. Loughead, aye; Dr. Wright, aye; Ms. Young, aye; Dr. Hatfield,
aye; Ms. Mumford, aye; Ms. Gullett, aye; Dr. Bertch-Mumaw, aye and Dr. Christensen, aye.
Motion passed unanimously.

After further discussion and consideration, a motion was made by Ms. Mumford and
seconded by Dr. Serbin to find Dr. Wanick in violation of A.R.S. § 32-2232 (12) as it relates to
R3-11-501 (1) for failure to provided professionally acceptable procedures for not
documenting the condition of the animal post-operatively. Roll call: Dr. Serbin, aye; Mr.
Loughead, aye; Dr. Wright, aye; Ms. Young, aye; Dr. Hatfield, aye; Ms. Mumford, aye; Ms.
Gullett, aye; Dr. Bertch-Mumaw, aye and Dr. Christensen, aye. Motion passed unanimously,

5. 14-75: In Re: Gary Yocham, D.V.M.
Dr. Yocham was present, made statements and answered questions. Ms. Linda Navasitis
was present, made statements and answered questions. After discussion and consideration,
a motion was made by Dr. Hatfield and seconded by Dr. Serbin to find Dr. Yocham in
violation of A.R.S. § 32-2232 (21) as it relates to A.A.C. R3-11-502 (L):

*(2) failure to record the dog's weight in the medical record January 21st through

January 28th of 2014;

« (4) failure to record examination findings of the dog during hospitalization;

*(7) (a) and (b) failure to record the concentration and amount of Gentamycin used on

January 20, 2014;

*(7) (b) failure to record the amount of fluids administered to the dog; and

*(7) (c) failure to record the frequency of Ampicillin administered to the dog.
Roll call: Dr. Serbin, aye; Mr. Loughead, aye; Dr. Wright, aye; Ms. Young, aye; Dr. Hatfield,
aye; Ms. Mumford, aye; Ms. Gullett, aye; Dr. Bertch-Mumaw, aye and Dr. Christensen, aye.
Motion passed unanimously.

After further discussion and consideration, a motion was made by Dr. Hatfield and
seconded by Dr. Serbin to find Dr. Yocham in violation of A.R.S. § 32-2232 (11) Gross
negligence; causing unnecessary suffering or death due to:

*Continuing Gentamycin to a dog with known kidney issues resulting in renal failure and

concurrent death;

*Inadequate fluid administration to a dog with a serious condition;

e Lack of adequate pain management resulting in the animal suffering;

«Not performing a urinalysis; and

*Sending the dog home when in renal failure.
Roll call: Dr. Serbin, aye; Mr. Loughead, aye: Dr. Wright, aye; Ms. Young, aye; Dr. Haifield,
aye; Ms. Mumford, aye; Ms. Gullett, aye; Dr. Bertch-Mumaw, aye and Dr, Christensen, nay.
Motion passed 8 ayes, 1 nay (Dr. Christensen).

Arizona State Veterinary Medical Examining Board - September 17, 2014 - Final

6. 14-76: In Re: Mario Tascon, D.V.M
Dr. Tascon was present, made statements and answered questions. Ms. Linda Navasitis was
present, made statements and answered questions. After discussion and consideration, a
motion was made by Dr. Hatfield and seconded by Dr. Serbin to find Dr. Tascon in violation
of A.R.S. § 32-2232 (21) as it relates to A.A.C. R3-11-502 (L):

*(2) failure to record the dog's weight in the medical record January 25! and January

26! of 2014;

(4) failure to record examination findings of the dog during hospitalization; and

*(7) (b) failure to record the amount of fluids administered to the dog.
Roll call: Dr. Serbin, aye; Mr. Loughead, aye; Dr. Wright, aye; Ms. Young, absent; Dr. Hatfield,
aye; Ms. Mumford, aye; Ms. Gullett, aye; Dr. Bertch-Mumaw, aye and Dr. Christensen, aye.
Motion passed 8 ayes, 1 absent (Ms. Young).

After discussion and consideration, a motion was made by Dr. Hatfield and seconded by
Dr. Serbin to find Dr. Tascon in violation of A.R.S. § 32-2232 (12) as it relates to A.A.C. R3-11-
501 (1) failure to provide professionally acceptable procedures and the use of current
professional and scientific knowledge for:
*Not ensuring the dog was receiving an appropriate amount of fluids for dog's
condition;
*Not communicating the severity of the dog’s condition and prognosis to the pet owner
when he was overseeing the care of the dog over the weekend in question;
*Not ensuring the dog was receiving proper pain medication given the dog’s history
that a surgical procedure was performed on January 20!,
Roll call: Dr. Serbin, aye; Mr. Loughead, aye; Dr. Wright, aye; Ms. Young, absent; Dr, Hatfield,
aye; Ms. Mumford, aye; Ms. Gullett, aye; Dr. Berfch-Mumaw, aye and Dr. Christensen, aye.
Motion passed 8 ayes, | absent (Ms. Young).

7. 14-70: In Re: Tomas Teskey, D.V.M.

Ms. Mumford was recused. Dr. Teskey was present telephonically, made statements and
answered questions. Ms. Jill Breitner was present telephonically, made statements and
answered questions.

> At 4:27p.m., a motion was made by Dr. Christensen and seconded by Dr. Bertch-
Mumaw to go into executive session for legal advice. Motion passed, 7 ayes, 2
absent (Ms. Young and Ms. Gulleti).

> At 4:3lp.m., the Board entered back info open session.

After discussion and consideration, a motion was made by Dr. Christensen and seconded
by Dr. Hatfield to find Dr. Teskey in violation of A.R.S. § 32-2232 (12) as It relates to A.A.C, R3-
11-501 (1) failure to provide professionally acceptable procedures for not testing the horse’s
blood until five (5) days after collecting the sample. Roll call: Dr. Serbin, nay; Mr. Loughead,
nay; Dr. Wright, nay; Ms. Young, absent; Dr. Hatfield, aye; Ms. Mumford, recused; Ms. Gullett,
absent; Dr. Bertch-Mumaw, nay and Dr. Christensen, aye. Motion failed 2 ayes, 4 nays, 1
recusal and 2 absent (Ms. Young and Ms. Gulleit).

After further discussion and consideration, a motion was made by Dr. Christensen and
seconded by Dr. Hatfield to issue Dr. Teskey a Letter of Concern with respect to

Arizona State Veterinary Medical Examining Board ~ September 17, 2014 - Final

communicating to his boarders regarding who will be providing veterinary care for their
horses. Roll call: Dr. Serbin, aye; Mr. Loughead, aye; Dr. Wright, aye; Ms. Young, absent; Dr.
Hatfield, aye; Ms. Mumford, recused; Ms. Gullett, absent; Dr. Berftch-Mumaw, aye and Dr.
Christensen, aye. Motion passed 6 ayes, 1 recusal and 2 absent (Ms. Young and Ms. Gullett).

After further discussion and consideration, a motion was made by Dr. Serbin and seconded
by Dr. Hatfield to find Dr. Teskey in violation of A.R.S. § 32-2233 (B) (3) minor records
violations that are routine entries into a medical record and do not affect fhe diagnosis or
care of the animal - failure to document the address and phone number of the animal
owner in the medical record. Roll call: Dr. Serbin, aye; Mr. Loughead, aye; Dr. Wright, aye;
Ms. Young, absent; Dr. Hatfield, aye; Ms. Mumford, recused; Ms. Gullett, absent; Dr. Bertch-
Mumaw, aye and Dr. Christensen, aye. Motion passed 6 ayes, | recusal and 2 absent (Ms.
Young and Ms. Gullett).

. ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW OF PREVIOUS ACTIONS

1.11-99: In Re: Audie Wood, D.V.M. Board appearance in compliance with Board Order.
Dr. Wood was present in compliance with her Board Order, made statements and
answered questions. It was brought to the Board's attention that Dr. Wood's random urine
screen showed a dilute creatinine level and specific gravity that was in the acceptable
range by .0004; out of nineteen screens she has completed, five have indicated abnormal
levels for these two indicators. Dr. Wood indicated she drinks a lot of water, which may
impact these two indicators.

2.13-33: In Re: Greg Heltman, D.V.M. Board may review, discuss and take action on
Practice Monitor Reports.
Tabled for a future Board meeting.

3. C-14-12: In Re: Joe Robinson. Board may review and discuss injunction status.
Tabled for a future Board meeting.

4,14-27; In Re: Monica Bunge, D.V. M. Board may review, discuss and take action on
request to lift Suspension status and allow Dr. Bunge to return to work part-time.

Dr. Bunge was present telephonically, made statements and answered questions. After
discussion and consideration, a motion was made by Dr. Serbin and seconded by Dr.
Bertch-Mumaw to table this matter for a future Board meeting when Dr. Bunge has an
employment offer with details and has relayed her current status to the potential
responsible veterinarian. The Board will consider an emergency Board meeting if necessary.
Motion passed, 8 ayes, 1 absent (Ms. Young).

5. 14-64: In Re: Robert Burkhardt, C.V.T. Board may review, discuss and take action on
substance abuse evaluation.
Tabled for a future Board meeting.

Arizona State Veterinary Medical Examining Board - September 17, 2014 - Final

V. REPORTS, CORRESPONDENCE, REFERRALS AND OTHER BUSINESS

1,Board may review, discuss and fake action on certified veterinary technician application
from:
a. Alison Havird
Ms. Havird was present, made statements and answered questions. After discussion and
consideration a motion was made by Dr. Serbin and seconded by Ms. Gullett to
approve Ms. Havird’s CVT application and allow her fo sit for the exam(s}. Motion passed
unanimously.

2. Board may review, discuss and fake action on technician certification pending
submission of issuance fee.
. Vanessa Ballesteros
. Janine Brady
. Monica Bush
. Yolanda Clark
. Elizabeth D’Agnese
Joel Dame
. Allison Dark
. Malyn Gilbert
. Christopher Inscho
. Danielle Johnson
10. Diana Lehigh
11. Amanda Leon
12. Kelly Jo Leslie
13. Christina McCormick
14, Lindsay Matthews
15. Mark Romanoski
16. Samantha Saucedo
17. Ashley Stubbs
18, Eryn Tison
19. Laurel Trosper
20. Sarah Willis
After discussion and consideration, a motion was made by Ms. Young and seconded by Dr.
Bertch-Mumaw to approve the above technician certifications pending submission of their
issuance fee. Motion passed 7 ayes, 2 absent {Ms. Young and Ms. Gullett).

WONOMABRWH—

3.Board may review, discuss and take action on denial of certification for Certified
Veterinary Technician applicants who failed the VINE and/or State exam. List available
upon request.

After discussion and consideration, a motion was made by Ms. Mumford and seconded by
Dr. Bertch-Mumaw to deny certification for CVT applicants who failed the VINE and/or
State exam. Motion passed 7 ayes, 2 absent (Ms. Young and Ms. Gullett).

4,Board may review, discuss and take action on C-14-13, In Re: Thlago Moraes, unlicensed
practitioner.

After discussion and consideration, a motion was made by Dr. Christensen and seconded
by Dr. Hatfield to issue Mr. Moraes a Cease and Desist for the practice of veterinary
medicine. Motion passed 7 ayes, 2 absent (Ms. Young and Ms. Gullett).

Arizona State Veterinary Medical Examining Board - September 17, 2014 - Final

ts:

5.Board may review, discuss and take action on C-12-10, In Re: Kim Sheridan, unlicensed
practitioner, possibly continuing the practice of veterinary medicine after a cease and
desist issued.

Tabled for a future Board meeting.

6.Board may review, discuss and take actlon on review of AAVSB conference from Board
delegate and attendees.
Tabled for a future Board meeting.

7.Board may review, discuss and take action on reviewing Investigative Committee
member applications and may select applicants to interview at a later date.

After discussion and consideration, a motion was made by Dr. Serbin and seconded by Dr.
Hatfield to invite Donald Noah, D.V.M. to attend a future Board meeting to discuss his
possible appointment to the Investigative Committee. Motion passed, 7 ayes, 2 absent (Ms.
Young and Ms, Gullett).

8.Board may review, discuss and take action on adding to agency website a list of
licensees and certificate holders whose status is revoked, suspended, or on probation.
Tabled for a future Board meeting.

9, Board may review, discuss and take action on appointing a Legislative sub-committee.
Tabled for a future Board meeting.

10. Board may review, discuss and take action on review of veterinary licensure and
veterinary technician certification processes.
Tabled for a future Board meeting.

11. Board may review, discuss and take action on NAVLE ® Technical Report and
Quallfying Examination Technical Report.
Tabled for a future Board meeting.

12. Board may review, discuss and take action on agency response to ADOA/General
Accounting Office audit.
Tabled for a future Board meeting.

13. Board may review, discuss and take action on premise application for Catalina Animal
Hospital.
Ms. Whitmore updated the Board of the timeline of events associated with the premise
application for Catalina Animal Hospital, the subsequent premise inspection and the failure
to submit corrections of the violations found at the premise inspection. Ms. Whiimore
narrated a picture presentation of the premise inspection that had occurred. After
discussion and consideration, a motion was made by Dr. Serbin and seconded by Dr.
Berfch-Mumaw to deny Catalina Animal Hospital's premise application pursuant to:

« ARS. § 32-2274 (A) (2), (3) as outlined in the Board staff memo, (4), (5) and (6); and

e =A.R.S. § 32-2232 (13) fraud or misrepresentation in procuring a license.
Roll call: Dr. Serbin, aye; Mr. Loughead, aye; Dr. Wright, aye; Ms. Young, absent; Dr. Hatfield,
aye; Ms. Mumford, recused; Ms. Gullett, absent; Dr. Berfch-Mumaw, aye and Dr.
Christensen, aye. Motion passed 7 ayes, 2 absent (Ms. Young and Ms, Gullet#),

Ati

zona State Veterinary Medical Examining Board - Sepiember 17, 2014 - Final

14, Board may review, discuss and take action on designating underserved Arizona
communities for veterinary students participating in the Western Interstate Commission for
Higher Education (WICHE) Professional Student Exchange Program.

After discussion and consideration, a motion was made by Dr. Hatfield and seconded by Dr.
Bertch-Mumaw to uphold the Board's 2007 decision designating underserved Arizona
communities for the purpose of the WICHE program. These are Apache, Graham, Greenlee,
Navajo, Mohave and Yuma counties. Motion passed, 7 ayes, 2 absent {Ms. Young and Ms.
Gullett).

15, Executive Director Report
a. Anthem CVT program closure
b. Maricopa County Animal Care & Conirol Tour
c. Newsletter
d. Renewal process update
e. FY16 Budget Request and Strategic Plan
Tabled for a future Board meeting.

16. Board may review, discuss and take action on veterinary license pending submission of
license fee and/or proof of graduation.

a, Shannon Cochran (R)

b. Elyse Honikel (R)

c. Heather-Leigh Riedy (R)

d. Rita Sanders (R)

e. Erin Wessel (R)
After discussion and consideration, a motion was made by Ms. Mumford and seconded by
Dr. Bertch-Mumaw to approve the above veterinary licenses pending submission of their
license fee and/or proof of graduation. Motion passed, 7 ayes, 2 absent (Ms. Young and Ms.
Gullett).

Vi.

REVIEW AND APPROVAL OF MINUTES

August 20, 2014 Draft Regular Session

After discussion and consideration, a motion was made by Dr. Bertch-Mumaw and
seconded by Dr. Serbin to approve the regular session minutes as drafted. Motion passed
7ayes, 2 absent (Ms. Young and Ms. Gullett).

August 20, 2014 Draft Executive Session

After discussion and consideration, a motion was made by Dr. Bertch-Mumaw and
seconded by Ms. Mumford to approve the executive session minutes as amended. Motion
passed 7ayes, 2 absent (Ms. Young and Ms. Gullett).

Vil. CONSENT AGENDA

A. Approval to take State Veterinary Exam
1. Alcott, Cody (E}
2. Ells, Jordan (R)
3. Harris, Krystal (R}

‘Asizona State Veterinary Medical Examining Board — September 17, 2014 - Final

4, Jang, Jessica (R)}
5. MacLennan, Tressa (E}
6. Mancino, Joseph (E)
7. Meltesen, Holly (R)
8. Ries, Robert, {E}
9. Wingo, Kipp (E}
10. Gold, Jenifer {E)
Approval to take the State Veterinary Exam granted.

B. Approval to take Certified Veterinarian Technician Exams
1. Weizel, Jasmine
2. Green, Jessica
3. Ramos, Lindsay
4, Bowman, Hollie
5, Loyd, Thomas
6. Minopoli, Anthony
Approval to take Certified Veterinarian Technician Exams granted.

C. Approval of Temporary Permit

1. Alcott, Cody (E)

2. Harris, Krystal (R)

3. Jang, Jessica (R)

4, MacLennan, Tressa (E)
5. Meltesen, Holly (R)

6. Gold, Jenifer (E)

Approval of Temporary Permits granted.

D. Approval of Request for Reinstatement of Veterinary License
1. Churgin, Sarah
Approval of Veterinary License Reinstatements granted.

E. Approval of Reinstatement of Certified Veterinary Technician Certificate
1. Saulter, Tina
2. Simanton, Sara
Approval of Reinstatement of Certified Veterinary Technician Certificate granted.

F, Approval of Premise Licenses

1, R2265: Arizona Veterinary Oncology, PLLC. New Owner/Responsible Veterinarian. Eric
Boshoven, DVM.

2. R2266: Arizona Veterinary Oncology, PLLC. New Owner/Responsible Veterinarian. Eric
Boshoven, DVM.

3. R2267: Arizona Veterinary Oncology, PLLC. New Owner/Responsible Veterinarian. Eric
Boshoven, DVM.

4, R2269: Petsense. New Premise. Meredith Beard, DVM.

5, R2271: Altered Tails. New Responsible Veterinarian. Kellie Ayle, DVM.

6. R2272: Laveen Veterinary Center. New Premise. Evan Ware, DVM.

7. R2267: Sunrise Mobile Vet. New Premise. Meredith Beard, DVM.
F (4) Removed from Consent Agenda.
Approval of Premise Licenses granted.

Avizona State Veterinary Medical Examining Board — September 17, 2014 - Final

G. Random Premise Inspections
. PO201: Peoria Animal Hospital. Stephen Wanick, DVM.
. P0446: Spirit Mountain Animal Hospital. Mark Jennings, DVM.
. PO%66: Estrella Animal Hospital. William Joslin, DVM.
P0972: Durango Equine Veterinary Center. Lloyd Kloppe, DVM.
RO222: West Olive Animal Hospital. John Montana, DVM.
. RO828: Cali’s Spay/Neuter Clinic. Tammy Helzer, DVM.
. RO936: Goodyear Animal Hospital. Amy Schomburg, DVM.
. R1085: Spay Neuter Clinic. Aleck Burgess, DVM.
. R1395: Animal Hospital of Laveen. Thomas Watson, DVM.
10. R1409: Alta Sierra Veterinary Hospital PLLC. Kristin Bell, DVM.
11. RO718: Rural Animal Clinic. David Conti, DVM.
Approval of Random Premise Inspections granted.

WO ONAORWNH—

H. Approval of Premise Scope Change Requests
1. RO7Z18: Rural Animal Clinic. Add mobile unit. David Conti, DVM.
2. R2145: Animal Birth Control East. Add diagnostics and radiology. Gurushabd Khalsa,
DVM.
3. R1409: Alta Sierra Veterinary Hospital. Add mobile unit. Kristin Bell, DVM.
Approval of Premise Change of Scope Requests granted.

|. Approval of Premise Name Change Requests
1. R2241: Sonora Veterinary Specialists to Phoenix Veterinary Referral and Emergency
Center. Stephen Gilson, DVM.
Approval of Premise Name Change Requests granted.

J. Approval of Veterinary License
1. Cissell, James (E)
2. Dombeck, Joanna {E)
3. Revenaugh, Anna (S)
4. Yeamans, Carmen (E)
Approval of Veterinary Licenses granted.

After discussion and consideration, a motion was made by Ms. Mumford and seconded by Dr.
Wright fo approve the Consent Agenda as amended. Motion passed unanimously.

Items Removed From Consent Agenda

F (4) R2269: Petsense. New Premise. Meredith Beard, DVM.
No action taken.

VII, SUMMARY OF CURRENT EVENTS
No current events discussed.

IX. CALL TO PUBLIC
No member of the public wished to speak.

Arizona State Veterinary Medical Examining Board - September 17, 2014 - Fina

X, ESTABLISHMENT OF FUTURE MEETING DATE
The next regular meeting will be held telephonically on October 15, 2014, beginning at 8:30
a.m. at 9535 E, Doubletree Ranch Road, Scottsdale, Arizona, 85258, in the Board Room.

XI, ADJOURNMENT
The meeting adjourned at 5:25p.m.

Respecifully submitted,

one

Victoria Whitmore, Executive Director

Arizona State Veterinary Medical Examining Board — September